Some potentially heavy hitters slipped at the plate on their way to bat this holiday season.
Warner Bros. Animation banked big on the Dr. Seuss brand with their The Cat in The Hat film by promoting it in theaters for almost a year. Opening with $20 million shows not a lot of people were convinced. I mean, it’s a book most people can read in five minutes. What exactly were they expecting people to watch for 100 minutes?
Similarly, Ebenezer tried to launch a Christmas themed movie before Thanksgiving. It didn’t work for Red One two years ago and didn’t work this time either. Opening with $19 million, it’s hard to tell if people didn’t care about Johnny Depp or the 749th version of A Christmas Carol.
Meanwhile, Godzilla Minus Zero opened to a much larger debut than Minus One three years ago ($30 million vs. $11 million). Yet, that first film had great world of mouth and only dropped 25% in its second weekend. This time, Minus Zero dropped 72% in its second weekend despite a 90% on Rotten Tomatoes and 96% Popcorn score. That’s a crazy pants fall! Godzilla has survived for over 70 years but no “blockbuster” film survives that.
Sadly, even some films you may have thought wouldn’t really work really didn’t. How to Rob a Bank didn’t steal anything with a $5 million debut. Also, Ghost Soldier has already been ghosted after an $8 million five-day start. Likewise, Drummer Boy couldn’t keep the beat with $16 million after ten days in the theaters.
Hopefully, all these films were just the appetizers and the main courses are just about to drop in Week 3. I don’t think we can handle anything else from the pu pu platter. This current Top Five list looks like some sort of old Netflix DVD queue I’d see on my parent’s computer and I’d change it without telling them.
The Top Five If Today Was MLK Day:
#1. Godzilla Minus Zero - $49 million
#2. The Cat in The Hat - $38 million
#3. Ebenezer - $19 million
#4. Drummer Boy - $16 million
#5. Wild Horse Nine - $13.3 million
*****
Extra Bonus Section
As per the Week 1 (or I guess Week 2 in this case) tradition here are my esteemed, extremely well thought-out and perpetually doomed to fail 2026 Holiday Blockbuster prognostications. Remember, I’m the guy who thought The SpongeBob Movie: Search for SquarePants was going to be a Top Five film in 2025. Genius!
So here’s what I think will happen...
#1. Avengers: Doomsday - I’m sure there’s no way the movie makes sense and the onslaught of cringe marketing tie-ins have already begun (Seriously, Kevin Feige, Jack-In-The-Box?! That’s who you went with here!), but anyone who’s ever bought a ticket to an Avengers film (and there’s A LOT of them) is going to be curious enough to at least check this one out once. I went with a $625 million by MLK total.
#2. Dune 3 - I really don’t have a clue what the IMAX exclusivity for this film is going to mean for its overall box-office total. I just know less people will see it than Doomsday, but more than any other film this holiday season. Oooh, and I’d love for Dune to explore the multiverse so Bob Dylan, Marty Supreme, and Wonka can all show up for the big battle at the end. Chalamets, assemble!
#4. The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping - Super excited about this film, yet the last prequel (and Jennifer Lawrence-less film) only delivered $166 million. That tells me the brand isn’t as strong as Jumanji, though no one makes mopey angst look this good. Sure, they’re all about to die, but they look like they’re walking down a runway doing it! #BlueSteel4Life
#5. Hexed - This is a complete guess/know nothing pick. Would love if Godzilla or Violent Night 2 could actually make the Top Five, but I doubt it. I even thought about Focker In-Law and Angry Bird Movie 3 (their last movies were much bigger hits than you likely would guess). I settled on the classic Disney hill I die on more often than not. I don’t think it’ll be Frozen or Zootopia, I just need it to not be Wish. Come on, little mousie, let’s do this!
Good luck, everyone!




